I have an Ikea highchair. It won't solve your snugness issue and may have a smaller tray than you want, but you can't beat the clean up or price ($25). It doesn't fold up, however, if you don't need it, the legs easily remove for storage (4 poles and a seat the size of a booster). One piece plastic easy cleaning. I use their big bibs with front pockets and arms too.
http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/30069724
